The "excluded moment"
is here.
Define the space between
zero and one.
The space between breadths,
the sliver of an instant after moment ends; before moment
begins. Begin.
It is a quandary made
especially salient by a postmodern understanding of space
and time, an understanding which has been reflected and in
many cases anticipated by our culture�s art. It is a puzzle
which signifies the ways in which Western thought�s tradition
of binary oppositions no longer describes our increasingly
complex reality (binary oppositions being the juxtaposition
of "opposites" which supposedly make a cohesive
whole reality; male/female, good/evil, and so on). It is a
question which realizes the significance of the smallest most
basic particle of reality, or really, the lack of such a basic
particle of reality. When Einstein tells us that we can no
longer think of space and time as a backdrop against which
our lives are played out, but rather as the fabric of which
our lives are composed, where does this leave us? When quantum
physics reminds us that there is no way of being sure that
the smallest point of matter really exists at all, but that
atoms are nothing more solid than swiftly moving energy, how
can our concepts of time, space, motion, language, or selfhood
remain the same? Indeed, how can one place faith in any idea
of a static subjectivity?
Today�s digital media
are a physical manifestation of this understanding of interconnectedness
within systems of living as well as the antimatter we now
recognize as being the fundamental building blocks of reality.
This idea relates to binary systems in technology, new discoveries
in transmission of information within the Internet, as well
as themes in art and literature concerning the nature of space,
time, and self. Modernist authors were among the first to
recognize the implications of an underlying web of communication,
which now represents itself in the Internet. Visionary artists
such as Virginia Woolf and James Joyce explored this web of
reality, realizing the different layers of reality that exist
simultaneously, and this concept�s impact on a person�s sense
of self. In the spirit of the Internet, science has mimicked
art, with the discovery of atomic theory, multiple dimensions,
quantum physics, and the superstring theory. Postmodern critics
and theorists such as Deleuze and Guattari have mused on these
various connections and offered explanations for this new
direction of thought by proposing a psychology for contemporary
society�s new patterns.
Wait: Deleuze and Guattari.
Here is their metaphor
for an unseen condition of irrational connections. Just as
an Internet search engine brings up random flurries of similarities
(according to the keyword entered), so does Deleuze and Guattari�s
rhizome rupture between organizations and connect disparate
elements.
Rhizome: There is a structure,
a plane of consistency in all things: This is your body, your
subconscious, society, this is the Internet. This body is
all structure, defined simply by its filling a space to a
certain point. This territory is predictable, is mundane,
and takes care of the partial objects in it. Organs within
a body, thoughts within a consciousness, hyperlinks within
a website. But the body is unable to sustain itself by these
contained series of blips. It is rebelling against this organization.
It really really sustains itself by a certain deterritorialization,
a rare rupture, "a line of flight" out of the certain
limit of itself and into the certain limit of another territory,
because it then becomes �not�, and is able to see itself in
the absence. This is rhizomatic ecstasy: a rhizome being a
root that connects partial objects to partial objects.
Machine: Guattari coined
this term to escape the pesky notion of self, the "�subject�
which is often mistaken for consciousness itself. A machine
is any point at which a flow of some sort (physical, intellectual,
emotional, etc.) either leaves or enters a structure."
Example: the mouth-anus
engine is a representation of the uncharted flights of sustenance
within everyday eating. The movement of rhizomes is the bridging
of space between zero and one, as occurs in any binary code.
Thus it is necessary for rhizomatic rupture within a program
because a program�s agency depends on the changes between
its smallest parts (zeros and ones, or ons and offs). Video
as well relies on change between frames, since it is the moving*
of the frames that creates an image, just as it is the
reader�s act of reading that connects the words to make a
novel or poem. Each video frame is divided into two interlaced,
layered fields. Each field consists of multiple lines, which
create the unified image we see. And so it is true in physics
today as well, with the superstring theory proposing the presence
of blinking interdimensional strings within each electron
and neutron, that the physical world consists of fields of
dimensions with strings blinking through each one of the fields.
Therefore, a computer screen blinks, a televised image blinks,
a table, a window, even a human body, all blinking. We are
living in continual strobe.
Epileptic Mama
And you ask, oh come on,
I am an organization of blinking? I am some epileptic mama?
Yes. Oh, yes.
James Joyce and VA Woolf
both understood and anticipated this layered flickering reality.
For Woolf, it was most significant in its effects on a person�s
subjecthood. How can one have faith in an idea of a unified,
solid, tangible self, knowing that we are composed of energy,
flickering in and out of dimensions, real and unreal at the
same time? In Woolf�s experimental, lyrical novel The Waves,
six characters reveal their perceptions and innermost revelations
through a series of monologues. One of the six, Bernard, says,
"What am I? I ask. This? No, I am that�then it becomes
clear that I am not one and simple, but complex and many."
Later, Louis acknowledges this same truth, saying that he
has become aware "that these attempts to say, �I am this,
I am that,� which we make, coming together, like separated
parts of one body and soul, are false." Still later in
the book, Bernard realizes that they six are all petals on
the same flower.
Likewise, in A Portrait
of the Artist as a Young Man, James Joyce expresses the
rhizomatic epiphany, a stampede of the patterns of life. Within
the cry "Stephen Dedalus! Bous Stephenoumenous!"
which ignites Stephen�s most substantial epiphany, is the
word �noumenon.� A noumenon is the direct object of the Numen,
the �recording energy� that snags it, insensibly. The Numen
disrupts the mundane cubicle of living patterns and "causes
absolute decoded flows of desire" and "undoes all
territorialities." This is a function of Stephen�s realization
of the connectedness of disparate particles which substantiates
reality.
Arguably, we now are existing
in an age of intersubjectivity, like the characters in The
Waves, like Stephen Dedalus. "Subjectivities have
always been networked � context based�the internet has given
us a powerful externalising metaphor for our own immersion
and constitution by and through the slop and flow of social
intercourse � through language or semiotic system. Deleuze
and Guattari recognised this in the implicit cyberorganisation
of the body without organs." See! We weren�t making it
up.
Time.
The idea of time which started
with the Modernists is a manifestation, not of a singular
rhizome�s organization or rupture, but in fact, it is a representation
of the entire process of stability and movement, of containment
and release for the rhizomes in the system. Likewise, one
of this idea�s scientific counterparts, Einstein�s theory
of relativity, expresses the ways in which space and time
are inextricably linked, and are changeable. Time is the conscious
equivalent to the movement of, within, around, involving every
ablative of the rhizome. This movement that �time� represents
is the constant behind every changing event in this
process: a rhizome�s organization, corruption, and eventual
rupture into another rhizome within the system. This constant
is a paradox: it is unending movement, it produces instability
in all organized structure, but it, itself, is the only �stable�
thing within all of life, through it�s consistency of inconsistency,
in it�s unchanging process of change. Therefore, it could
be argued that �time�, which stands as a metaphorical symbol
for a constant that is incomprehensible, also stands
then as human being�s conceptual symbol for a spiritual entity
which is the unnamable, ungraspable unit of existence. Therefore,
VA Woolf�s obsession with time, a theme prominent in many
of her works including The Waves, is actually a spiritual
search for the harmonious constant.
Time:
Oh Boy
Time is a paradoxical process.
In each moment that it designates, it recreates and destroys
itself all at once. It always is, and always isn�t,
continually disappearing into its next new self. VA demonstrates
this impeccably with the image of the waves: "The waves
broke and spread their waters swiftly over the shore. One
after another they massed themselves and fell�.the waves fell;
withdrew and fell again, like the thud of a great beast stamping."
The waves are a consistently reoccurring beat of tide; one
wave washes out the last path of the wave before it, while,
at the same time, recasting it�s own inevitably impermanent
path, which is erased immediately in the next beat. �Time�
is the paradox of infinite resurrection. Like the written
word, it must be consumed for it to exist and move on.
*
Movement: Here Goes Nothing
Everything occurs within time.
Actions have reactions necessarily constructed in them; they
ebb and tow throughout life. Time is the backdrop and carrier
of these things, these actions; time is the movement behind
them: so what is �movement�? It is destruction and reconstruction;
it is the making of mess and the clean-up of mess. Movement
isn�t an object, it cannot be held, but also, it is made up
by every object and matter that changes. There�s a paradox!
Within every atom, there is change.
Super String Theory: "In
some sense what string theory does is that it stretches �
smears out � point particles into loops of string." Used
to help define the nature of the smallest particles in nature.
But wait�doesn�t that sound just like video? The epileptic
mama is back?! Super string theory also allows for the existence
of multiple dimensions, much as modernist and postmodern art
allows for many different layers of reality. "Bosonic
strings vibrate �counterclockwise� (it�s just a convention)
in 26 dimensions while super strings resonate �counterclockwise�
in the more standard ten dimensions. With one more dimension
for the thickness of the string itself it allows for eleven
or twelve dimensions." It also echoes the way electronic
music breaks down sound into its smallest particles and remixes
disparate sounds. This metaphor works for experimental video
and other manifestations of technological art as well.
There is a continual flux
within all matter, but movement isn�t contained within that
matter; it is the continuation of that matter�s change. So
what is �change�? Change is the presence of inconsistency:
when something changes, it becomes nothing for a moment, it
disappears in its disorganization. So movement is essentially
the presence of inconstancy, the demonstration of unmaking.
There it goes: nothing. A paradox, you ask? Of course.
A
Rhizome: The Big One
Technology
was the giant rhizome that erupted the physical world of the
early-mid twentieth century through scientific inventions
and discoveries, thereby destroying the stability in scientific
theorems and hypothesizes, and disrupting the set specification
of man�s control over natural power ( with the atom bomb).
This set up an immediate reaction for society mentally, where
as, previously one could find comfort in certain set institutions
of thought, now life and all the living were extremely vulnerable
again. Society was spiritually dislodged as well, since all
trust in a divine will, in an immutable destiny, was erased,
and replaced with instability of every moment. The reassurances
of the Christian time-line, and of a predicted but distant
apocalypse, had been shattered, and the new modern time, one
of consistent impending doom, had erected in its place. In
reaction to theses changes set forth by the technological
rhizome, human beings each experienced a copy-cat rupture,
and broke from their comfortable isolations of organization,
in an attempt to replace what had been lost: the sense of
structure, the god of stability.
Not
only has this emergence of technology screwed with art, it
has created art of its own. Digital technologies are naturally
an effective medium with which to confront these issues of
binary ruptures of the time-space continuum. For example,
video physically manifests this idea of the excluded moment,
of reality residing in the changes between connected but disparate
moments. The luminescence (the black and white part) of a
video transmission lies exactly precisely between zero and
one volt; the energy which defines the images exists solely
within this fluctuation.
And then there�s
this guy.
Deleuze: "
The different internments of spaces of enclosure through which
the individual passes are independent variables: each time
one of us is supposed to start from zero, and although a common
language for all these places exists, it is analogical.
On the other hand, the different control mechanisms are inseparable
variations, forming a system of variable geometry the language
of which is numeral (which doesn�t necessarily mean binary)."
So.
The space between zero
and one involves the process of a word being read, devoured,
discarded, transformed in one�s head to represent and finally
create an alternate reality. The space between zero and one
is the reading of the word, not the word itself. It is the
meta-word. It is the transduction process, similar to how
today�s technology changes information into electrical pulses
which in turn create a sound on the telephone or a picture
on a computer screen. It is our understanding and acceptance
of the reality of the book. And it is not just written language;
language is simply a convenient example. It is all art, and
the idea is especially relevant to digital multi-media artwork.
The meta-video, the mind�s reconstruction of flickering images
into a fair approximation of reality. The act of reading,
of seeing, is the space between.
Likewise, a computer program
is comprised of how zero and one change. It is the change,
the transmutation, the connecting of disparate flickering
elements, which constitutes movement or what we perceive as
progressing time. It is this web of connected but separate
points, and the movements between them which constitutes our
technology, science, art, and social context. It is this constant
shimmering flux which illustrates our late 20th,
and very very early 21st (hey, it�s January) ideas
of ourselves.
And there you have it.
Or maybe, you don�t.